Should my young athlete get a trophy just for participating?

This question is sometimes hotly debated within sports organizations as well as within families.

There is the school of though that if you haven't earned it you shouldn't get a trophy/medal:

There aren't any participation trophy's in life, so don't expectations that they are owed something just for participating.
If a sport keeps score then there are those that win and those that don't, participation trophy's don't reward the right goal.
Participation trophy's diminish the value of trophy's that are earned by the fastest, best, most accurate... name your measure. That gives a kid something to strive for.
If you want to reward them for making every practice or attending every game, that great but awarding kids who don't making all the practices or games diminishes the effort put out by those that do.

Then there is the school of thought that a participation for everyone, regardless of effort is a good thing:

It's worth a couple of dollars to give kids a big smile, and participation awards do not cause long term damage or build entitlement in kids.
Participation trophy's boost confidence and tells athletes that though they may not have won, they gave it a good effort.
They give a kid a sense of accomplishment by participating in the sport.
It helps to build a child's self esteem.

Is it a good thing or something that should be avoided? Where do you land on this topic?

Comments

The 11 Rules to successful Dadding

I don't know how many billions of Dad's there are out there in the world, but that's at least how many different opinions there are on being a Dad. While we might be able to reasonably discount a few, every one of those opinions are just that... an opinion and no better or worse than yours or mine.

So, with that premise, and knowing that some may agree with me, some may disagree, but most won't care one way or the other, I present to you the
2019 Dadding Today List for Dad's
First, let's start off with the "it's okay to" list and give yourself permission to openly and frequently exercise these. As a Dad it’s okayTo say I was wrongTo say I’m sorryTo say I don’t know (however, you should also look at numbers 3 through 7 below)
Now onto what I like to refer to as the "Learned from personal experience" list Your wife is always right. I'm serious here. Share your opinion but if she is adamant about her position you need to let it go and give …

A Day At The Game

My wife got us all tickets to a Seattle Mariners game this past Sunday. One of the things that I was hoping to come from this game was to teach my son how to do baseball score keeping. More on that in a bit

This past Sunday was our semi-regular annual day at a Mariners game. Except for last year we have taken the twins to at least one of the Seattle Mariners home games each year and as the kids have gotten older the enjoyment has the improved, both theirs and mine.
The other reason that we do this is that we have a new Au Pair each year and it gives them an American cultural experience. There was a time not too long ago when a Chevy commercial went something like “As American as Baseball, hot dogs, apple pie and Chevrolet” so this is a great slice of American culture to share with international visitors. This year we also had our Au Pair's dad visiting with us for a couple of weeks from South Africa, and her boyfriend was also joining us, so anticipation and excitement was high.
I…

KGOY - Kids Getting Older Younger

Please Note: Since this was a bit more preachy and a downer then I had originally intended I have included a link to a video that I created and posted on youtube several years ago on memories from my youth to help lighten the mood of this blog
---------------------------------------------------

KGOY - I did not make that up, I promise.

But it is a reality that I have clearly seen, probably better than most since I raised my oldest daughter and son starting in the mid 80's.

30 years later and the differences between the two times is not always fully appreciated by many of today's parents. My 11 year old's are learning stuff in the 5th grade that I did not even learn until High School.

When I was a kid (I can hear the grumbling now "here we go") we had one TV. A black and white with rabbit ears and 3 networks (ABC, NBC, CBS) plus a couple of PBS and the like.

Being the youngest, I had no say in what we watched so, depending on the show, I sometimes enjoyed the adver…

Search This Blog